While there are numerous options for purchasing a foam mattress online, the Casper and Tuft & Needle are consistently highly rated by customers and industry experts. Before diving deeper into what makes each mattress unique, know that both have similar return policies, warranties, and shipping methods. However, we wanted to explore the strengths and weaknesses of both brands, so we looked at nine unique categories to make it easier for you to choose between the two.
Right from the start, the Casper mattress sets itself apart from the Tuft & Needle with a hybrid foam construction. It is comprised of four separate layers: a responsive poly foam, memory foam, supportive poly foam, and base layer foam. With double the layers of the Tuft & Needle, the Casper’s construction aims to support with dense poly foam while simultaneously offering comfort through memory foam. Wrapping these foam layers together is a thin, white and grey polyester fabric cover that allows for increased airflow, especially beneficial for those who get hot while sleeping.
With only two layers of foam, the Tuft & Needle has a minimalist construction that still offers a sinking comfort and supportive base. The top layer is a unique poly foam designed by the company to be both responsive and breathable. Below that is a supportive poly foam base that is meant to counter the top layer’s cushion and provide a comfortable balance between the two. Similar to the Casper, the Tuft & Needle’s mattress cover is a white polyester/nylon blend that is incredibly thin and breathable. While this is ideal for keeping sleeper’s cool, is also means the dark top layer of foam is slightly visible through the cover.
Although the Casper mattress is made up of four foam layers relative to the Tuft & Needle’s two layers, the Casper is 9.5 inches thick while the Tuft & Needle measures in at 10 inches thick. Despite the difference, remember that thickness isn’t the only factor to consider when choosing which mattress is best for you. Below, we share why you should think of your favorite sleeping position, price point, and ideal firmness before making a final decision.
Both the Casper and Tuft & Needle are made of foam, so it’s not surprising they weigh in very close to each other. However, the Casper is slightly heavier than the Tuft & Needle in every size—possibly due to the heavier poly and support foam layers. While weight is a factor to consider when moving, rotating, and lifting the mattresses, it’s not noticeable enough to make or break your choice between the two.
Giving an accurate time frame on how long both mattresses will last is not possible yet, since the brands have not been around long enough to live out their respective 10-year warranties. However, through projections, foam testing, and multi-year use, the industry review expert Sleep Like the Dead gives the Casper an estimated 7+ year durability rating and the Tuft & Needle a 6.5 year durability rating.
Choosing a mattress based on your preferred sleeping position is essential, as proper weight distribution is directly related to overall comfort. For side sleepers who put more weight on shoulders and hips, a mattress should absorb pressure but also provide enough support to keep your body aligned. Comparatively, back and side sleepers should consider how much cushion or support they enjoy to avoid an uncomfortable sinking or floating feeling.
When looking at customer and expert reviews for back sleepers using the Casper versus the Tuft & Needle, there is only one small difference in overall satisfaction. While average (130-230 lbs) sleepers and large (+230lb) sleepers found both mattresses to be comfortable, small sleepers (under 130 lbs) rated the Casper marginally above the Tuft & Needle. This difference in comfort could be caused by the layer of memory foam in the Casper that offers a sinking feeling for lighter sleepers as opposed to a floating feeling in the Tuft & Needle.
Fitting with this idea, large side sleepers found the opposite to be true. These sleepers need more support for their shoulders and hips, so they rated the Tuft & Needle higher than the Casper for overall comfort. However, average side sleepers found both mattresses to be equally satisfactory with a “good” rating, while small side sleepers rated both brands as “good to fair”.
The main difference in these two mattresses lies in the reviews of stomach sleepers. For this position, average and small sleepers gave the Casper a “good” rating, while larger people found the comfort level to be “fair”. Stomach sleepers using the Tuft & Needle were most satisfied when they were average size, while small and large people rated the mattress as “good to fair”.
If you enjoy a firm mattress, you may have a tough time choosing between the Casper and Tuft & Needle without considering your size and ideal sleeping position. According to the industry review site Sleepopolis, the Tuft & Needle has a firmness rating of 6-6.5 out of 10, while the Casper has a rating of 6-7 out of 10. Without much difference in rating, it’s important to remember that smaller sleepers tend to find the Casper more comfortable while larger sleepers were satisfied with the Tuft & Needle.
Although many foam mattresses available today have very similar price ranges, there can still be a difference of several hundred dollars between brands. For these two mattresses, the Casper comes in at a higher price point, with a range from $550–$1,150. The Tuft & Needle is slightly less, with a price range between $350–$750. No matter which you choose, keep in mind that your budget, the mattress size, your sleep position, and how often it will be used comes into play. For more detailed prices by brand and size, take a glance at our chart below:
Because the Tuft & Needle mattress has been on the market longer than the Casper mattress, there are significantly more reviews available. However, we calculated the average of all customer satisfaction ratings, Amazon reviews, and rating analysis by industry experts. By looking at the comparison chart below, you’ll see each source has slightly difference ratings. Sleepopolis gave both mattresses the same overall rating, while Sleep Like the Dead gave the Casper 1% higher than the Tuft & Needle. However, the Tuft & Needle brought in slightly higher customer satisfaction reviews on Amazon. Explore the rating chart below and remember to consider sleeping habits, weight, and price when making your decision.
Similar to many other purchase decisions in life, the best mattress for you truly depends on your unique habits, budget, sleeping position, and desired firmness. If you’re considering the Casper, know that it is ideal for sleepers looking for a mattress that hugs your body and has a slightly firmer feel. On the other hand, the Tuft & Needle mattress is ideal for sleepers who prefer a medium to medium-firm feel, want to avoid sinking too much, and would like the best deal available in the foam mattress market. Before buying, look back through our charts and remember to consider every factor. We hope you have an easier time choosing between the two after finding this review!