Bedowl brings together the products best for your bedroom. If you choose to buy our picks, we earn affiliate commissions that support our work. See how we make money.
Katrina Kirsch
Dec 15, 2017
04

Loom and Leaf vs. Casper

Compare Icon

Compare

Build Icon

Build

Feel Icon

Feel

Pricing Icon

Pricing

We looked through 8,311 customer comments and reviews from mattress experts to create this comprehensive side-by-side comparison. So, which is the best mattress for you: Casper or Loom & Leaf? See for yourself at a glance:
Loom and Leaf
(4.5/5)
Firmness
Medium to firm
Cover fabric
Organic cotton
Thickness
12 in.
Weight
No range
Material
2 in. memory foam; 2.5 in. visco memory foam; 2 in. transition foam; 5.5 in. support foam
Price range
$650 - $1800
Shipping
Paid
Trial period
120 nights
Warranty
15 years
Available sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
SHOP The Mattress
details
Sorry, no coupon available
Casper
(4.3/5)
Firmness
Medium
Cover fabric
Polyester blend
Thickness
9.5 in.
Weight
55 - 104 lb.
Material
1.5 in. responsive foam; 1.5 in. memory foam; 1.5 in. poly foam; 5 in. support foam
Price range
$550 - $1,150
Shipping
Free
Trial period
100 nights
Warranty
10 years
Available sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Shop The Mattress
Sorry, no coupon available.
Key Comparisons

In this comparison, we're looking at two of the foam mattress industry's top competitors—the sleek, popular Casper and the natural, luxurious Loom & Leaf. Both companies were created as spin-offs from traditional mattress brands, so the designs should reflect years of sleep experience. To see how each company used this expertise to create the best possible mattress, we compared the designs across nine key categories. Ready to find out which is best for you? Read on to get one step closer to a good night's sleep.

What is each mattress made from?

Looking first at the trendy Casper, this mattress construction was designed to suit as many sleepers as possible. It's a hybrid foam designed composed of four layers, meant to offer an ideal level of support and comfort. The first layer is a responsive poly-foam that provides comfort, cooling, and bounce as an initial contact for sleepers. Next comes a thin layer of memory foam, ideal for absorbing weight, offering pressure relief, and adding support.

Diagram showing the foam layers of the Casper mattress.
‍Figure 1: Diagram showing the foam layers of the Casper mattress.

While memory foam tends to retain heat, Casper's use of it as a second layer avoids direct contact. The third layer of foam is a poly-blend that acts as a transition between the top comfort layers and the bottom support base, allowing room for heavier sleepers to sink in without immediately feeling the base foam. Finally, the base foam rounds out the Casper's construction and acts as a foundation for the entire design. As a cover for these layers, Casper uses a two-toned design. The top is a soft, white polyester fabric that allows for air circulation, while the sides are a sturdier polyester-blend that prevent wear and tear to the inner foam.

Going one layer further than Casper, the Loom & Leaf foam mattress is made up of four foam layers and one gel cooling layer. What makes this construction unique is the use of incredibly high-quality materials. On first contact, sleepers sink into a gel-infused foam layer meant for cooling and comfort. This layer of foam includes the same cooling gel that is used for hospitalized burn victims. While an impressive fact, it also lives up to the cooling performance it promises. After this layer comes the memory foam. Known for being supportive, this high-density foam acts as a core for the design to give comfort, contour, and compression relief.

Diagram showing the foam layer construction of the Loom & Leaf mattress.
Figure 2: Diagram showing the foam layer construction of the Loom & Leaf mattress.

Similar to Casper, the Loom & Leaf has a third layer of transitional foam that gives all size sleepers the same smooth feeling of support. Rounding out the mattress is a high-density support foam that provides shape and support. Wrapping these layers is a lush cover. The top fabric is 100% organic cotton and is quilted with a ⅝ inch layer of foam. While you sink into this fabric, you can also rest easy knowing there is an organic fire-retardant layer made of thistles woven into the cover. To finish the design, there is a gold thread piping border to aid durability and give it a high-end look.

How thick is each mattress?

Considering the layer differences of Casper and Loom & Leaf, it's no surprise the Loom & Leaf weighs slightly more than Casper. Looking at a standard Queen size, the Casper mattress weighs in at 83 pounds, and the Loom & Leaf comes in at 93 pounds. While this difference is slight, it will make turning a Loom & Leaf mattress a bit more difficult. However, it is more important to consider firmness, feel, sleeping positions, and price above weight. Keep reading to learn what we found about these qualities for both designs.

Thickness (in.)

How much does each weigh?

Considering the layer differences of Casper and Loom & Leaf, it's no surprise the Loom & Leaf weighs slightly more than Casper. Looking at a standard Queen size, the Casper mattress weighs in at 83 pounds, and the Loom & Leaf comes in at 93 pounds. While this difference is slight, it will make turning a Loom & Leaf mattress a bit more difficult. However, it is more important to consider firmness, feel, sleeping positions, and price above weight. Keep reading to learn what we found about these qualities for both designs.

Weight of queen (lb.)

Will they stand the test of time?

Durability of foam mattress has been been a topic of debate among traditional mattress companies. Although foam has garnered criticism, both Casper and Loom & Leaf offer good warranties and return policies. Loom & Leaf has a 15-year warranty with a 120-night trial, and Casper offers customers a 10-year warranty with a 100-night trial.

Although neither company has been around long enough to put these policies to the test, the mattress review website Sleep Like the Dead created a durability rating scale based on material types. Estimating how long each material holds up under normal use, the scale gives rankings of "good", "fair", and "poor". According to this scale, the Casper received a "good" rating of 7+ years, while the Loom & Leaf was given a "fair" rating of 6.5 years. If this criteria is one of your top priorities when picking a mattress, it may be best to look into each company's customer service reviews and return claims to see how they have been handled.

Durability (1-7)

What type of sleeping position is each mattress suitable for?

When choosing a mattress, it's common to lay down and test the comfort level from every position possible. However, most people tend to switch between one or two positions at night. To find the mattress that will be most comfortable for you, think of how you fall asleep and wake up. If you're a back, side, or stomach sleeper (or all of the above), look at the ratings Sleep Like the Dead pulled together based test sleepers from each position. For all positions, the sleepers ranged from large (230+ pounds), average (130-230 pounds), and small (under 130 pounds).

Settling into the side sleeping position first, we evaluated whether Casper or Loom & Leaf was more comfortable for customers. Sleep testers gave Casper a mix of reviews, with average individuals giving it the best "good" rating. Large sleepers found it to be "fair", while small sleepers rated Casper "good to fair". Since Casper's goal was to produce a mattress for the majority of people, it's no surprise the average weight class was most satisfied. Looking to Loom & Leaf side sleepers, both large and average testers gave the mattress a "good to fair" rating. Small sleepers found it to be less comfortable and therefore agreed on a "fair" rating. For all side sleepers, it's important to consider the thickness and comfort level since pressure causes hips and shoulders to sink further into the mattress.

Switching from side to stomach, the mattress reviews for these sleepers showed similar trends as above. Casper was rated "good" for average and small stomach sleepers, but larger individuals may have experienced too much sinkage because they ranked the mattress "fair". Loom & Leaf was "good" for average sleepers, but small and large individuals rated it "fair"—possibly due to the firmer feel and desire for more cushion as a stomach sleeper.

Flipping onto the back, both mattresses received the best ratings for this position. Casper was ranked "good" from large, average, and small sleepers, while Loom & Leaf was awarded a "good" rating for large and average individuals. However, small back sleepers gave Loom & Leaf a slightly lower "good to fair" rating.

Which one is firmest?

While most people find an average firmness level comfortable, foam mattresses have become increasingly complex in their designs to fulfill the needs of a wider variety of people. To meet this demand, Loom & Leaf offers two levels of firmness—a Relaxed Firm and a Firm mattress. The Relaxed Firm is given a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale, while the Firm is awarded an 8 out of 10. Looking to Casper, the company currently offers one design that falls as a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale. However, heavier customers have reported Casper can feel firmer, like a 7 out of 10. This is likely due to increased sinkage, which brings sleepers in contact with the firmer support foam layers.

FIrmness (1-7)

How much does each mattress cost?

For almost all foam mattress options, the price is going to be less than buying a traditional mattress from a brick-and-mortar store. When debating price, it's also good to consider the shipping policies, trial periods, included services, and warranties. Yet, looking to the Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses, there is a notable price difference. Since Loom & Leaf uses high-quality and organic materials, the cost is higher than Casper for all size mattresses. This makes Casper a good value, but it also makes Loom & Leaf a great value for the materials included. To see the specific prices by size, look to our chart below:

Price of Queen (USD)

Which has the highest customer ratings?

Depending on where you look, the customer ratings differ for each mattress. We pulled reviews from popular websites such as Amazon, Sleepopolis, Sleep Like the Dead. Plus, we compiled the averages from reviews from across the web. For some, Casper won out. For others, Loom & Leaf was the clear winner. On Amazon, Casper had a 4.3 star-rating to Loom & Leaf's 4.1 stars. Even so, Sleepopolis gave Loom & Leaf a 97% satisfaction rating and Casper a 86% rating. While it's good to consider customer reviews, there brands are close enough that others factors such as sleeping position, firmness, and price should be looked at first.

Customer Satisfaction (1-5)

So, which is better?

Now that you've read the comparison, do you have a feeling which mattress is the best? You probably feel like we do—the satisfaction really depends on personal sleeping habits and needs. That being said, the Casper and Loom & Leaf definitely have their differences. If you're searching for a mattress that will be comfortable for average sleepers, is a good value, and has an average firmness, the Casper is probably the right choice for you. On the other hand, you can't go wrong with the Loom & Leaf if you're looking for an option that uses natural materials, has a luxurious feel, is a good value relative to the traditional competition, and is firmer. No matter your decision, we hope you find one that will help you sleep soundly.