If you’re trying to decide between a Leesa and a Tuft & Needle mattress, this comprehensive look will give you a clear picture of the advantages and disadvantages of each. What’s notable right from the start is that both mattresses can be bought online and come with great return policies. However, there are distinct differences between the two brands, so let’s take a closer look at which mattress might be the ideal buy for you. Here's our Leesa vs. Tuft and Needle comparison.
Looking first at the Leesa mattress, we found it is made of three unique foam layers. These hybrid layers work together to bring out the best properties of each material. The top Avena foam is perfect for comfort and cooling, while the middle memory foam layer offers pressure relief, and the bottom layer brings in major support. Adding to the soft feel of this mattress is its original gray and white striped cover. Made of a single piece of polyester and lycra, the fabric is breathable and light.
Offering its own individual benefits is the Tuft & Needle mattress. Not a true hybrid mattress, this design is comprised of two foam layers. The top layer is a high-performance poly-foam created by Tuft & Needle that offers incredible support and sinking comfort. The bottom layer is a thick support foam that acts as a sturdy foundation. Following along with Tuft & Needle’s brand, the cover is minimalistic and completely white. Bearing no detail other than the brand name, the polyester nylon blend cover is thinner than most, which may allow for more effective cooling.
While both the Leesa and the Tuft & Needle mattresses measure in at 10”, they offer different levels of firmness and comfort for each type of sleeper. The Leesa offers 4” of comfort foam, while the Tuft & Needle has 3” to cradle sleepers. However, the Tuft & Needle provides 7” of support foam to the Leesa’s 6” of heavier base foam.
Since both the Leesa and Tuft & Needle mattresses are composed of foam layers, the weights are very similar. Likely due to the lighter layer of support foam, the Leesa weighs in slightly under the Tuft & Needle on every size. However, both are comparable when considering how easy it is to move, lift, and rotate the mattresses.
Although purchasing a mattress online has become more and more popular over the years, some shoppers might question how durable a foam construction truly is. After looking through customer reviews and comparisons by the industry expert Sleep Like the Dead, we discovered both brands have a fair durability rating and are likely to retain their comfort and shape for around 6.5 years. However, Leesa and Tuft & Needle haven’t been around long enough to make this estimate accurate, but both companies have 10-year warranties and excellent customer service.
When considering which mattress to buy, it’s important to understand your preferences and ideal sleeping style. Side sleepers typically need more cushion due to increased pressure, while back sleepers can lean towards firmer mattresses for support. No matter your style, you can find out whether the Leesa or Tuft & Needle will work best for you based on the rankings from Sleep Like the Dead explained below.
The Leesa is known to be softer than the Tuft & Needle and offer more pressure-relief. For back sleepers, large (+230 pounds) and average-sized (130-230 pounds) sleepers tend to find the Leesa comfortable with the right amount of support. Small back sleepers rate their experience with this mattress as “good to fair.” Side sleepers who are large and average-sized also rated the Leesa as “good to fair” but smaller people found it to be “fair.” For stomach sleepers using this mattress, the best rating was given by average sleepers. Large sleepers found it to be “good to fair” while smaller people gave it a rating of “fair.”
Comparatively, the Tuft & Needle mattress is also comfortable for a variety of sleepers, depending on their size and sleeping style. Those who mainly sleep on their back give the Tuft & Needle “good” rating, with large and average sleepers finding the most satisfaction. Smaller back sleepers rank it in the middle as “good to fair.” For side sleepers, this mattress is best for average-sized people, but larger and smaller customers still rated it above average as “good to fair.” Lastly, stomach sleepers concluded similar results with a ranking of “good” for average sleepers, and “good to fair” for larger and smaller people.
In this category, it is clear that the Tuft & Needle is firmer. Likely due to the thick support foam base and lack of memory foam, this mattress is rated a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. In comparison, the Leesa mattress received a close 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale. If you’re looking for more support, the Tuft & Needle could be the right choice for you. Keep in mind, it is important to consider your sleeping style and costs when picking between the two.
Price is a major factor when making a purchase as large and important as a mattress. While many foam mattresses are in a very similar price range, it is clear in this comparison that the Tuft & Needle is less expensive with a range of $400-$900. If you do have a strict budget, it is important to know that the Leesa is a bit pricer at $525-$1,070. Look at our table below for the exact prices by size:
Since the Tuft & Needle mattress has been available for several years, there are many more reviews than the Leesa mattress. However, we looked at the percentage of customer satisfaction, Amazon customer reviews, and analysis by industry experts. As you will see in the comparison chart below, the ratings mainly depends on the source. Sleepopolis ranked the Leesa above the Tuft & Needle, while the Tuft & Needle brought in slightly higher Amazon reviews. Check out the rating chart below and remember to consider other factors when picking your perfect mattress.
As we showed above, the overall ratings truly depends on sleeping style, habits, price point, and firmness. If you’re looking for a medium-firm design that is comfortable for a wide variety of sleepers and sleeping positions, you may want to consider the Leesa above the Tuft & Needle. On the other hand, the Tuft & Needle offers more support for sleepers who do not like to sink into their mattress. Plus, it has an unbeatable price point compared to other foam mattresses on the market. Before making a final decision, make sure to look back through this comparison and weigh in all the factors for you and possibly your partner. Happy sleeping!